Understanding Twelve-Step Programs

Elevator to sobriety out; use the steps
For 40 years I have had people ask why I would/how I could work with people who have a substance use disorder.  I have stopped trying to answer the question in such a way as to help the asker appreciate my reasons.  Instead, I ask what prompts the question.

Frequently I hear something along the lines of how difficult "those people" are to work with or how frustrating/heartbreaking/exasperating it is to try and facilitate change with someone who "just is not ready."  Instead of an answer intended to change the views of someone who has likely already made up his or her mind about "those people," I ask if they have ever visited places where "the changed" congregate.  I generally get a look that communicates, "what are you talking about" to which I say, "You know...to a 12-step meeting."  Invariably the answer is no.

If anyone has doubts that individuals with substance use disorders change, they need go no further than the nearest "open" AA or NA meeting, take a seat at the back of the room, settle in, and just listen.  The stories of recovery range from heartbreaking to hilarious, but they are all genuine and inspirational.

If you have ever wondered about addiction or are curious about what leads someone with a substance use disorder to pursue change, then attending several open 12-step meetings is highly recommended.  If this sounds like something you might consider, here are some guidelines I provide to my students when directing them to attend meetings as part of my Introduction to Addictive Disorders class.  Considering them may make attending a bit less intimidating and significantly more enjoyable:

What to Expect When Attending “Open” 12-Step Meetings:
 Suggestionsregarding Etiquette


1.    Unlessyou are personally addicted to the substance being addressed at a particular12-step meeting, e.g., alcohol at an AA meeting, only attend "open"meetings of a 12-step group. "Open" meetings are just that, open toanyone who may want to attend a meeting or learn more about the 12-step programof recovery.
2.    Expectto be greeted at the door when you arrive. The greeter may shake hands occasionallys/he may offer a "hug" (this is not all that common). Be prepared forthe greeter to ask something like, "Is this you first meeting?" or"Have you been to a ___ meeting before?" Do not hesitate to say thatyou are attending because you want to learn more about ___ meetings and this ispart of a class assignment. Ask to be sure that the meeting is"open."
3.    Whilerare, do not be surprised if the person becomes a bit "cool" if yousay you are attending as a student in order to learn (this is more likelyindicative of the person's lack of confidence when speaking with "aprofessional" than a rejection of you as a person or "outsider."Remember that "open" meetings are open to anyone.
4.   Unlessadvertised as a "non-smoking" meeting, expect smoking.
5.    Expectthe meetings to last between 1 and 1.5 hours. Some will take a brief breakafter 30 - 45 minutes (usually the smoke-free meetings).
6.    Mostmeetings begin with some variation of the following ritual - the SerenityPrayer, greetings from the "chair" for the evening, a reading of the12-step (perhaps the 12-traditions), perhaps a reading from the big book orother 12-step literature to set the stage for the group.
7.    Expectthe chair to ask if there are any new comers attending for the first time. DONOT feel obligated to raise your hand. If you do, expect to be personallywelcomed. It is also likely that someone will approach you at the break orafter the meeting and ask if you have questions. DO NOT hesitate to say you area student and attending the meeting to learn. The person may appear"cool," but this is probably because s/he felt comfortableapproaching you as a new comer to the program, i.e., an addict, but isuncomfortable speaking with you as "a counselor."
8.    Expect that a basket will be passed fordonations. DO NOT feel obligated to put something in the basket, but if you do,$1 is plenty.
9.   Do not be surprised if you are asked toread something or asked if you would care to speak. I suggest reading theparagraph or step or whatever, but as regards speaking, just say, "I'mhere to learn and would like to pass" or something of the sort.
10.      Do not hesitate to let anyone know youare a student and why you are there. MOST members are pleased to answerquestions and may even tell you how pleased they are that you are.
111.        Do not be surprised if someoneapproaches you after the meeting and offers you her/his phone number. This iscommon practice and part of the tradition of helping, NOT someone trying to hiton you.
112.        Consider attending the meetings with afriend, preferably someone from the class. This will assuage the anxiousnesssome students experience when attending their first meeting. It is also anexcellent way to process the experience after the meeting - remember, you haveto write a paper on your experience attending the meetings.

    Enjoy yourself   
    Dr. Robert

» Read More...


An Argument for Harm Reduction to Address Collegiate Drinking

HarmReduction (HR) and its utility as an approach to address substance use isnothing if not controversial. Although most are aware of HR as regards Methadone maintenance or Needle Exchange, but there is more tothis behavioral and public policy objective than these two strategies.

Inbrief, HR is about considering ways to engage individuals committed to a particularpattern of behavior so as to reduce the likelihood of their doing harm to themselves and/orthe community in which they reside and operate.  For a brief overview of HR as it applies tocollegiate drinking, visit this article that you may find useful as regardsjustifying HR techniques and strategies when looking to approach a high-riskcommunity (an indicated population) in a pre-contemplative (not ready) stageof readiness to change.  Visit http://peele.net/lib/reducing.htmland scrolldown to, Is Harm Reduction a Viable Policy forAmerican Collegiate Drinking?

In brief, our biggest challenge in addressing the concerns relatedto HR is that arguments against such policies tend to be grounded in moral and/orlegal principles while the rationale for HR is steeped in public health andquality of life issues.  Until and unless both sides of the HR debate canfind a common ground where they can talk about the issue in neutral terms,there will always be more heat than light generated by this debate.

It seems to me that our challenge is to level the proverbial playingfield.  Those advocating HR as one strategy in a comprehensive plan toaddress collegiate drinking will never trump the moral and legal rhetoric directedagainst HR with a logic-based appeal that addresses the quality of life ofthose who choose to use.  You and I can likely appreciate this logic and asthe result embrace it, but for those who see drug use as “illegal” and those whouse drugs as “criminals”—or its first cousin, “if drugs are bad then those whouse them are bad people”—HR is tantamount to “giving in,” “permitting use,”“the first step to legalization,” and/or “pushing current non-users towardsuse.”

An alternative in this debate is to shift the focus for HRaway from the reduction of harm for the user and direct it instead onto thereduction of harm for the community in which the user uses.  In thecase of the Greeks, a high-risk community of drinkers on college and university campuses, for example, it is improving the quality of life for thecommunity in which the Greeks live (this is where programs like the Good Neighbor Project at Clarion Universityin Clarion, PA can be useful – see http://www.clarion.edu/267773/) orreducing costs to the university related to violence and vandalism.  If acase can be made to lower high-risk Greek drinking, its related behaviors, and its negative impacton quality of life issues in general, especially if those quality of life issuesaffect student decisions to transfer before graduation, then one can argue forHR not so much to benefit to “miscreant drinkers,” but the individual“well-behaved student” in the general university community.

Put another way, if there are “indicated populations” that alreadymanifest indications of problems related to drinking on campus, then theuniversity community as a whole--and not just the errant consumers--is the most likely benefactor of the HR effortstargeting those communities.

What do you think?

Dr. Robert

» Read More...

Buscar

Blog archive